Thamer Kadum Yousif,
MBchB / FICMS
Assistant Professor, College of Medicine,
Tikrit University
|
ABSTRACT
Background: Belgian astronomer
Quetelet observed in 1869 that among
adults of normal body mass, weight
was proportional to the square of
height. In 1972 Keys and colleagues
made a similar observation and named
it body mass index (BMI). This index
is a measurement of choice for most
physicians and researchers. A BMI
between 20-25 kg/m² is regarded
as a good weight for most individuals.
Overweight is defined as BMI above
25 kg/m² and obesity defined
as BMI above 30 kg/m². BMI less
than 20 kg/m² is considered as
insufficient weight.
The aim of this study: is to
learn the trends and extendt of the
overweight, obesity and to examine
the nutritional state of the community.
We also wanted to estimate the prevalence
of obesity, malnutrition and study
the association of high BMI with diabetes,
hypertension and a family history
of hypertension and diabetes. Additionally
we wanted to study the association
of BMI estimation with dietary habits,
smoking, physical activity, ethnicity,
educational status and other factors.
Methodology: Is a community
based crosssectional study,
in the period 1st to 31st of August
, 2003, 17 clusters had been chosen
from Daquq town and its villages,
ncluding 89 families and 424 persons
above 13 years of age. We measured
the weight and the height of the subjects
and calculated the BMI of each subject,
A self-determined questionnaire had
also been answered by the subjects.
Results: We found that obesity
is more prevalent among females of
all age groups, e.g. 50% of females
above 64 years of age have a BMI of
> 30 in comparison with males 16%
for same age group. Also rural subjects
have higher BMI than urban subjects.
Mean of BMI of married individuals
(male 26.1, female 27.3) is higher
than unmarried (male 22.7, female
23.3). Housewives have a highest BMI
(23% of them have BMI equal or more
than 30) while students have the lowest
BMI (1.6% have BMI equal or more than
30). Illiterate people are more obese
(22.6% of them have BMI equal or more
than 30) than educated. There was
no negative relation between smoking
and obesity, but ex-smokers were heavier
than non-smokers and those who never
smoked. Ethnic variation showed that
mean BMI in Turkman was (25.7), in
Kurds (24.7) and in Arabs (23.8).
Diabetic and hypertensive people have
a higher BMI. 67% of diabetic and
42.5% of hypertensive patients have
BMI equal or more than 30. Those with
a family history of these two diseases
also have a higher BMI than others.
Regarding dietary habits, the BMI
increased by increase in the consumption
of bread.
Conclusion and recommendation:
This study showed that high BMI
and obesity are more common among
females, rural people, married, illiterate,
housewives, diabetic, hypertensive,
those with a family history of diabetes
and hypertension, and those with a
high bread consumption, and we recommend
that care and attention should be
taken toward risk groups and encouraging
awareness in people about their weight
and physical fitness.
|
Belgian
astronomer Quetelet observed in 1869 that
among adults of normal body weightt, weight
was proportional to the square of height.
In other words W/H² was constant. This
useful index is therefore called Quetelets
index (QI). Keys and colleagues in 1972
made similar observation, and named it body
mass index. [1]
This index or formula is now
the most widely used method for estimating
body weight of the population. A BMI between
20-25 kg/m² is usually considered a
good weight for most individuals. Overweight
is defined as BMI above 27 kg/m², and
obesity defined as BMI above 30 kg/m².
BMI index less than 20 kg/m² is regarded
as insufficient weight, indicating malnutrition
or chronic disease. Weight gain may confer
increased health risk; in women a weight
gain of more than 5 kgs is associated with
increased risk of diabetes and heart disease.
In men any weight gain after the age of
25 appears to carry increased health risks.
[2]
The determinants of weight
gain and obesity have proven to be multifactorial
but inconsistent. In follow-up studies of
factors predicting weight change, for example,
fat intake, physical activity, smoking,
alcohol consumption and other factors have
yielded no conclusive evidence that these
factors either promote or prevent weight
gain.
Our society is becoming
increasingly obesogenic, thus although obesity
has a strong genetic background, environmental
factors are regarded to be the underlying
cause of an increase in obesity by promoting
the problem. In Britain, for example, the
increase in the prevalence of obesity was
attributed to a reduced level of physical
activity rather than intake of energy dense
food. Analysis of these studies are usually
based on population level estimates of environmental
factors. Studies in which an increase in
BMI is examined in relation to other variables
within the same population, are scarce.
[6]
To study the trends and extent
of overweight, obesity and examine the nutritional
status of the community.
Our objectives are to:-
1. Estimate the prevalence of obesity in
the population.
2. Estimate the malnutrition state in our
population and effect of the socio-economic
situation.
3. Study the association of BMI with diabetes,
hypertension, and other disease.
4. Study BMI association with family history
of diabetes and hypertension.
5. Study BMI association with dietary habits,
smoking, physical activity, employment,
ethnic groups, educational state and other
factors.
Subjects:
Daquq is one of the districts of Kirkuk
governorate. It lies 40 kilometers south
of Kirkuk, 220 kilometers north-east of
the capital Baghdad. Its geographical area
is composed of a small town and about 90
villages. Inhabited by 50,000 citizens of
multiple ethnic groups, they work mainly
in agriculture and trading.
In a community based cross-sectional
study, in the period from 1st to 31st of
August-2003, we took 17 clusters; seven
of them are from all the quarters of the
town, and ten from the villages. Each cluster
composed of 5 families selected in a systematic
random way; we included all the members
of the families above 13 years of age excluding
pregnant and handicapped persons. The villages
were selected for the study by dividing
the geographical area into 5 sectors according
to transportation way. From each sector
we chose 2 villages in a simple random way.
The total subjects were 424
persons from 89 families, 216 males and
208 females. 200 were from the urban area
and 224 from the rural area.
Setting:
Urban area: Al-resala, Door al-mazraa,
Al-qadisea, Al-hurea, Al-yarmook, Al-naser
and 17th July quarters in Daquq town.
Rural area: Zend bin ez, Zend mulla
yousif, Albu najim, Albu shihab, Sumaga
ulia, Zaglawa, Tobzawa, Al-wahda, Abdulla
ghanim sagher, Al-emmam villages.
Measurements:
For each subject we measured weight by electronic
weight scale, which was adopted from UNICEF
for the primary health centers. The subjects
wore light clothing and no shoes. Weight
was measured to an accuracy of 100 gm and
height measured by tape method. BMI was
computed as weight/height 2 in meters. We
used BMI mean and BMI of 30, 25 and 20 to
investigate the association with other variables.
For each subject we prepared
a set of self-administered questionnaires
including personal data about age, sex,
occupation, residence, marital state, ethnicity,
smoking, educational state, history of general
diseases, family history of general diseases,
physical activity, leisure time spending,
dietary habits, tea consumption, alcohol
consumption, and subjects perception
about their current health.
Regarding smoking, the subjects
were defined as smokers, never smoked, and
ex-smokers, ex-smokers defined as those
who gave up smoking for at least 6 months,
those with less than 6 months regarded as
smokers.
In physical activity questions
we divided subjects according to activity
in their employment and out of employment
activities, for example, farmers, laborers,
are regarded as being involved in heavy
physical activity, housewives, students,
non-sedentary governmental employees would
be regarded as being involved in moderate
physical activity. Unemployed, retired,
and sedentary governmental employees are
regarded as light physical activity.
In leisure time activities
we asked about sports activity, TV watching,
reading and others. Those with regular daily
sport activity were regarded as engaging
in high physical activity.
Questions regarding dietary
habits were about meat, milk, fruit and
vegetables dessert and its consumption daily,
weekly, and monthly. Regarding bread consumption
we asked about the number of slices consumed
per day.
Tea consumption questions
determined how many cups were consumed per
day by each subject.
We asked finally, each subjects
opinion about his health status as bad,
moderate or good.
Statistical analyses:
The two statistical tests t-test and chi-square
were used in analyses, in addition to the
SPSS version 10 software.
Obesity was more prevalent in females than
males of all age groups especially older
age groups both in urban and rural areas.
(Table
1)
- BMI was higher in
rural area than urban areas, for both
sexes.( Table2,
Table
3)
- Overweight (BMI 25-29.9)
was more in males, while obesity (BMI
equal and more than 30) more prevalent
in females. (Table
4)
- The results of marital
states show that 54.3% of the populations
are unmarried and 42% are married. BMI
mean was higher among married than unmarried
for both sexes. (Figure
3)
|
|
- Married female n=59,
mean BMI=27.3, SD=5. Unmarried female
n=78 mean BMI=23.3, SD=5.4. Married male
n=71, mean BMI=26.1, SD=4.6. Unmarried
male n=113, mean BMI=22.7, SD=4.
- The occupations of
the sample population (Figure
4)) were 38.9% housewives, 17.9%
free business, 14% students, 12.5% governmental
employees, 6.3% retired, 4.4% farmers,
2.3% unemployed and others.
- The obesity was more
prevalent among housewives 23%, and less
in students 1.6%. (Table
5)
- Educational state
results revealed that 36.5% of the population
are illiterate, 35.6% with primary school
education, 7.8% with intermediate education,
9.4% with secondary education, 10% with
college education and 0.4% with higher
education (Figure
5). The BMI relation to the educational
state seems to be high among illiterate
and those with college educational states.
(Table
6)
- There was no significant
difference in BMI mean between smokers
and those who never smoked, but the mean
was high in ex-smokers. (Table
7)
- Regarding the ethnic
groups in Daquq we found that Turkman
BMI mean (25.7) was higher than Kurds
BMI mean (24.7) and Arabs BMI mean (23.8).
(Figure
6)
- The BMI was significantly
high in hypertensive, diabetic and those
people who have both hypertension and
diabetes. (Table
8)
- The BMI was also
high significantly in those with a family
history of hypertension and diabetes.
(Table
9)
- Physical activity
relationship with high BMI was not significant
regarding the degree of physical activity
whether light, moderate or heavy activities.
(Table
10)
- Most people 64%
(272, n=424) spent their leisure time
watching television and others unfortunately
have not many other choices as to how
to spend their leisure time. Among TV
watchers 15% had a BMI of more than 30.
- We found in the results
of dietary habits of the sample, that
more than 95% of have at least one serving
of milk products, fruits and vegetables
per day for.
- In meat consumption
there was no strong association between
frequent meat consumption and high BMI
(Table
11). Most of the sample 73% (310,
n=424) have at least one meat meal per
week.
- Tea consumption has
no significant relationship with high
BMI. (Table
12)
- In dessert consumption
the association was also weak. (Table
13)
- In bread consumption
there was a remarkable increase in BMI
with increase in bread consumption. (Table
14)
- The peoples
awareness about their health differs.
The results of the questions about every
subjects evaluation of their own
health show that a significant percentage
feel good although their BMI was above
and below the normal ranges. (Table
15)
Iraqis
in general have lived in an unstable socioeconomic
and political situation in the last three
decades and still, this abnormal situation
affects the peoples lifestyle, although
the food rations that were provided by the
government made minimum food requirements
available for all Iraq population, and saved
them from starvation.
Obesity and high BMI was more
in females than males, this result is similar
to other studies in other countries. But
in our study the percentages were higher
for all age groups than females of same
age groups of other studies; this may be
due to several factors including repeated
pregnancies, joblessness, and inactive housewives,
when comparing them to women in U.K, Finland
and USA where the females are more active
and having less pregnancies than women in
Iraq.[1,2,3]
The obesity and overweight
was more in married than unmarried for both
sexes.This may be due to change in dietary
habits after marriage. Most married women
are housewives; they spend most of their
time in the kitchen preparing meals, and
housekeeping. Most Iraqis believe that marriage
is the symbol of stability and settlement
in the home. I think this idea makes married
people more committed to their responsibilities
and they are more stable mentally and physically
to involve in unmotivated or unreasonable
activities. [13,14]
In most populations, smokers
weigh less than non-smokers. As suggested
by Molarius et al, this is may no longer
be true especially in countries with extensive
antismoking activities and reduced prevalence
of smoking. This relationship was positive
in 1980 by Marti et al. Other studies show
no association. In our study we did not
find any association, and we found that
ex-smokers were heavier than smokers and
those who have never smoked. [18,22]
We found that Turkmans are
more overweight or obese than Kurds and
Arabs, and Kurds are more obese than Arabs.
This may be due to racial difference, and
it may be that Turkmans are concerned about
their food more than Kurds and Arabs. [3]
Obesity and overweight was
higher in rural areas than urban This may
be explained by the fact that the peoples
incomes were remarkably higher than in the
urban area in the last decade.
The occupation effect on body
weight revealed,as mentioned before, that
housewives carried the highest risk of obesity
and its complications. [22, 29] Next to
that is the sedentary life of employees
and other jobs, which lack physical activity.
Illiterate people seems to
be heavier than others, maybe due to lack
of nutrition knowledge and its effect on
health. [18] Most studies and literature
agreed that hypertension and diabetes are
strongly associated with obesity. Our results
were significantly consistentwith this theory
and we found that those with a family history
of these two diseases are more obese than
those without a family history. [21] Unfortunately
most Iraqis have not many choices on how
to spend leisure time; this may be an important
factor that affects peoples health.
Most of the people may not
have the opportunity to buy or to eat meat
daily. This may affect other aspects of
their health, and make it difficult to study
its association to obesity. In a cross-sectional
study with 7,410 males and 7,257 females,
Jacobson BK, Thelle DS, found that a weak
positive association was present between
fish and ground meat consumption. This was
true in our study too. [25]
Jacobson also found that high
BMI was most strongly associated with low
bread consumption and this result was reached
by many other studies in western countries.
But in our study we found that BMI increased
with high consumption of bread. This may
be due to the difference in the dietary
habits between our country and western countries,
by the fact that bread is the main item
in the menu of the majority of Iraqis and
there is no substitution for this item.
While this is not true in a western food
menu, where bread may be substitute for
heavy dense food items. [26,28]
Macdiarmid JI, Vail A, Cade
JE, Blundell JE, found that a high BMI was
positively associated with a high intake
of dessert or high fat sweet products (chocolate,
cakes, biscuits), but in this study we found
a weak association. It may be due to low
consumption of these products in general,
because of the socio-economic state. Only
60% of the sample can buy these products
or prepare ithem once a week, and 27% can
do that monthly. [18]
In tea consumption we found
a weak negative association with high BMI.
Many studies in the west support the theory
of this association. [31]
Peoples perception about
their health reflects knowledge, concern,
and education. When we asked the subjects
opinion about their health status we evaluated
their judgment about their health, and also
looked for social and cultural facts and
beliefs that make people think that obesity
is a sign of health. We found that only
23.2% of those with BMI of equal or more
than 30 think that their health state is
bad, and only 31.8% of those under BMI of
20 think that their health is bad. This
makes a conclusion that our people not concerned
or ignore their body weight and its relation
to health and disease.[18]
We asked about alcohol consumption
throughout the study but fortunately we
did not find any subjects.
- High BMI and obesity were
more prevalent among females.
- High BMI and obesity were
higher in rural area than urban.
- BMI was variable among
ethnic groups.
- Housewives were
heavier in weight than other occupation
groups.
- Unmarried people have lower
BMI than married.
- Illiterate people have
higher BMI than other educated groups.
- Smoking has no association
with BMI, but ex-smokers are heavier than
smokers and non smokers.
- Diabetics, hypertensives,
and those with a family history of diabetes
and hypertension have higher BMI than
others.
- Meat, dessert, and tea
consumption have a weak association with
BMI.
- Increase in bread consumption
leads to increase in BMI.
- Most people do not care
about their body weight.
- Attention should be taken
towards those who are at high risk of
developing, obesity,
i.e. females in general, and housewives
particularly, by adopting prevention programs
and extensive health education programs,
including healthy nutrition and adequate
physical exercise.
- Sedentary lifestyles must
be improved by physical activities, by
exercise programs and encouraging public
efforts towards establishing fitness centers
and support clubs to improve health and
quality of life.
- Changing community attitudes
and beliefs about obesity and health,
by defeating the idea that the obesity
is a sign of healthy living and replaced
it with the fact that ideal weight is
a sign of mental and physical wellbeing.
- This subject needs
more studies and research in the future
in our country, because by preventing
obesity we prevent a list of killer diseases
in the community.
- Recently
another chart of BMI was adopted with
percentiles for children above two years
of age. This needs study in our country
in order to depend on one index of nutritional
assessment throughout life.

Click here to view
the following:
Figure 1,
Figure 2
|
1. |
D.J Weatherall,
J.G.G Ledingham, D.A Warrell. Oxford
textbook of medicine. Oxford. Oxford
university press. 1996. 1320. |
2. |
Braunwald,
Isselbacher, Petersdorf, Wilson, Martin
and Fauci. Harrisons principles
of internal medicine. McGraw-Hill.15th
edition. (CD-ROM) |
3. |
Katherine.M.Flegal,
Margaret.d.Carrol, Cynthia. L.Ogden
and Clifford. L.Johnson. The prevalence
and trends in obesity among US adults
1999-2000, JAMA general practitioner
and dermatology 2003,III (2): 12-6. |
4. |
Sherwood NE,
Jeffery, French SA, Hannan PJ, Murray
DM. Predictors of weight gain in the
pound of prevention study. Int J Obes
Relat Metab Disord 2000; 24:395-430.
(Medline) |
5. |
Bouchard
C. Can obesity be prevented? Nut rev
1996; 54:s125-30. (Medline) |
6. |
Seidell JC.
Dietary fat and obesity: an epidemiologic
perspective. AM J Clin nutr 1998; 67
(suppl): 546s-50s. (Abstract) |
7. |
Willett WC.
Is dietary fat a major determinant of
body fat? Am J clin nutr 1988;67:556s-62s.
(Abstract) |
8. |
Klesges RC,
Klesges LM, Haddock CK, Eck LH. A longitudinal
analysis of the impact of dietary intake
and physical activity on weight change
in adults. Am J clin nutr 1992; 55:818-22.
(Abstract) |
9. |
Kant Ak, Graubard
Bi, Schatzkin A, Ballard-Barbash R.
Proportion of energy intake from fat
and subsequent weight change in the
NHANES I epidemiologic follow-up study.
Am J clin nutr 1995; 61:11-7. (Abstract) |
10. |
Reissan AM,
Heliovaara M, Knet P, Reunanen A, Aromma
A. Determinants of weight gain and overweight
in adult Finns. Eur J clin nutr 1991;
45:419-30. (Medline) |
11. |
Heitman
BL, lissner L, Sorenson TIA, Bengtsson
C. Dietary fat intake and weight gain
in women genetically predisposed for
obesity. Am J clin nutr 1995;61:1213-7.(Abstract) |
12. |
Colditz GA,
Willet WC, Stampfer MJ, London SJ, Segal
MR, Speizer FE. Pattern of weight change
and their relation to diet in a cohort
of healthy women. AM J clin nutr 1990;
51:1100-5. (Abstract) |
13. |
Dipietro
L. Physical activity in the prevention
of obesity: current evidence and research
issues Med sci excerc 1999; 31:s542-6.
(Abstract) |
14. |
Fogelholm
M, Kukkonen-Harjula K. Does physical
activity prevent weight gain
a systemic review? Obes rev 2000; 1:95-112. |
15. |
Molarius
A, Seidell JC, Kuulasmaa K, Dobson AJ,
San S. Smoking and relative body weight:
an international perspective from the
WHO MONICA project. J epidemiol community
health 1997; 51:252-60. (Abstract) |
16. |
Swinburn
B Egger G, Raza F. Dissecting obesogenic
environments: the development and application
of a framework for identifying and prioritizing
environmental interventions for obesity.
Prev Med 1999; 29:563-70. (Medline) |
17. |
Prentice
AM, Jebb SA. Obesity in Britain: gluttony
or sloth? BMJ 1995; 311:437-9. (Free
full text) |
18. |
Lahti
Koski M, Vartianen E, Mannisto
S, Pietinen P, age, education and occupation
as determinants of trends in BMI in
Finland from 1982 to 1997. Int j obes
relat metab disord 2000; 24:1669-76.
(Medline) |
19. |
Johnson RJ,
Wolinsky FD. The structure of health
status among older adults: disease disability,
functional limitation and perceived
health. J heath soc behave 1993; 34:105-21.
(Medline) |
|
|
20. |
Martikainen
P, Aromaa A, Heliovaara M. Reliability
pf perceived health by sex and age.
Soc sci med 1999; 48:1117-22. (Medline) |
21. |
Gutierrez-Fisac
JL, Regidor E, Rodriguez C. Trends in
obesity differences by educational level
in Spain. J clin epidemiol 1996; 49:351-4.
(Medline) |
22. |
Martinez-Gonzales
MA, Martinez JA, Hu FB, Gibney MJ, Kearney
J. Physical activity, sedentary lifestyle
and obesity in the European Union. Int
j obes relat metab disord 1999; 23:1192-201.
(Medline) |
23. |
Fentem PH,
Mockett SJ. Physical activity and body
composition: what do national surveys
reveal? Int j obes relat metab disord
1998; 22(suppl):s8-14. (Medline) |
24. |
Wareham NJ,
Rennie KL. The assessment of physical
activity in individuals and populations:
why try to be more precise about how
physical activity is addressed? Int
j obes relat metab disord 1999; 23:403-10.
(Medline) |
25. |
Cox DN, Perry
L, Moore PB, Vallis L, Mela DJ. Sensory
and hedonic association with macronutrients
and energy intakes of lean and obes
consumers. Int j obes relat metab disord
1999; 23:403-10. (Medline) |
26. |
Drewnoski
A, Kurth C, Holden-Wiltse J, Sarri J.
Food preferences in human obesity: carbohydrates
versus fats. Appetite 1992; 18:207-21.
(Medline) |
27. |
Rolls BJ,
Miller DL. Is the low fat message giving
people a license to eat more? J AM coll
nutr 1997; 16:535-43. (Abstract) |
28. |
Appleby PN,
Throgood M, Mann JI, Key TJ. Low BMI
in non meat eaters: the possible roles
of animal fat, dietary fiber and alcohol.
Int j obes relat metab disord 1998;
2:454-60. |
29. |
Stam
Moraga MC, Kolanowski J, Dramaix M,
De Backer G, Kornitzer MD. Sociodemographic
and nutritional determinants of obesity
in Belgium. Int J obes relat metab disord
1999; 23(suppl): 1-9. |
30. |
Tavani A,
Negri E, La Vecchia C. Determinants
of BMI: a study from northern Italy.
Int j obes relat metab disord 1994;
18:497-502. (Medline) |
31. |
Schwartz
B, Bischof HP, Kunze M. Coffee, tea
and lifestyle. Prev med 1994; 23:337-84.
(Medline) |
32. |
Molarius
A, Seidell JC. Differences in the association
between smoking and relative body weight
by educational level. Int j obes relat
metab disord 1997; 21:189-96. (Medline) |
33. |
Grunbergt
NE. Smoking cessation and weight gain.
N Engl J Med 1991; 324:768-9. (Medline) |
34. |
Laaksonen
M, Rahkonen O, Prattala R. Smoking status
and relative weight by educational level
in Finland, 1987-1995. Prev med 1998;
27:431-7. (Medline) |
35. |
Chen Y, Horne
SL, Dosman JA. The influence of smoking
cessation on body weight may be temporary.
Am j public health 1993; 83:1330-2.
(Medline) |
36. |
Simmons
G, Jackson R, Swinburn B, Yee RL. The
increasing prevalence of obesity in
New Zealand is it related to recent
trends in smoking and physical activity?
NZ med j 1996; 109:-2. (Medline) |
37. |
Boyle
CA, Dobson AJ, Egger G, Magnus P. Can
the increasing weight of Australians
be explained by the decreasing prevalence
of cigarette smoking? Int J obes relat
metab disord 1994; 18:55-60. (Medline) |
38. |
Seidell JC, Cigolini M, Deslypere J-P,
Charzewska J, Ellsinger B-M, Cruz A
body fat distribution in relation to
physical activity and smoking habits
in 38-year old European men. Am j epidemiol
1991; 133:257-65. (Medline) |
|