Editorial

Meet the team


Family Practice - a global perspective

The status of health and medicine in the Middle East - disease control


Histopathological relationship between severity of inflammatory reaction in gastritis and intensity of Helicobacter pylori in the antrum

Hypospadias: does the usage of Clomiphene citrate influence the incidence

Level of Hemoglobins in Sickle Cell Trait in Basrah using HPLC


Assure Safer Drug Therapy in the Middle East


An Investigation of Medical staff awareness of patients’ rights in Fasa hospitals and Medical centers

The investigation of effective factors on patients’ satisfaction Parent-Adolescent Relationships in the City of Amol


An epidemiological survey on maternal mortality rate and fatcors contributing to maternal mortality in rural area of Peshawar



Microdilution In Vitro Susceptibility Testing of 71 species of Dermatophytes isolated from pediatric cases in Nigeria against five antifungal agents


Development of Encounter Forms for Cardiovascular Disease Risk Management

 


Abdulrazak Abyad
MD, MPH, MBA, AGSF, AFCHSE

Editorial office:
Abyad Medical Center & Middle East Longevity Institute
Azmi Street, Abdo Center,
PO BOX 618
Tripoli, Lebanon

Phone: (961) 6-443684
Fax:     (961) 6-443685
Email:
aabyad@cyberia.net.lb

 
 

Lesley Pocock
medi+WORLD International
572 Burwood Road,
Hawthorn 3122
AUSTRALIA
Emai
l
: lesleypocock

 


An Epidemological Survey on Maternal Mortality Rate and Factors Contributing to Maternal Mortality in Rural Area of Peshwar

 
PRINCIPAL AUTHOR & CORRESPONDENCE

Mr. Hamzullah Khan
Final year MBBS
Khyber Medical College
Peshawar, Pakistan
Phone number: 0092-321-9020843
Email: hamza_kmc@yahoo.com

Mailing address:
Hamzullah khan,
Room No 104,
Qasim hall hostel
Khyber medical college
Post office: campus branch
University of Peshawar
Postal code: 25120, Peshawar, Pakistan

CO-AUTHORS

Professor Dr. Balqis Afridi
Professor of obstetrics and gynecology
Khyber Medical College
Peshawar, Pakistan

Dr. Ghulam Sarward
Associate Professor,
Community medicine,
Khyber medical college,
Peshawar, Pakistan.


ABSTRACT

Objectives:

  1. To determine the maternal mortality rate in the rural areas of Peshawar.
  2. To appreciate the factors contributing to maternal mortality.

Design: a descriptive observational survey

Setting: Palusai village near Peshawar University, Peshawar.

Duration: from December 2004 to December 2005.

Methods: Two hundreds houses were included in the study. Of those houses 400 women in their reproductive ages were selected. Five maternal deaths were recorded as a whole. Maternal mortality ratio was 4.73/1000 live births (5/1056), and percentage mortality was 1.25%. In Factors related to maternal mortality, 43% of the women living in kaccha (mud made) houses. Sixty one percent had drinking water supply from tube wells. Most of the women (49%)were living in houses with monthly income less than 5000/month. Sixty percent of the deliveries took place at home. Of total 57.5% women had no education. The age at marriage was between 16-20 years in 64% of the clients. Sixty two percent of the ladies missed to visit signally to antenatal care center in gestational period. The interval between two childbirths was less than two years for 59% cases. Thirty percent were vaccinated for TT only and 16% for both tetanus toxoid (TT) and measles, mump and rubella (MMR) during pregnancy. 72% had not utilized any iron supplements during pregnancy.

Conclusion: Socioeconomic, marital and obstetric factors are still major causes of maternal deaths.

Key words: MMR, Risk factors of MMR, Rural area, Peshawar, Pakistan.

INTRODUCTION

Globally, progress in improving the survival and well being of mothers has been slow, and this holds true for the Eastern Mediterranean Region. Thus at the current pace, it is unlikely that the Millennium Development Goal related improving maternal health will be achieved in the Region by the year 2015.[1] An estimated 400,000 infant and 16,500 maternal deaths occur annually in Pakistan. These translate into an infant mortality rate and maternal mortality ratio that should be unacceptable to any state. Disease states including communicable diseases and reproductive health (RH) problems, which are largely preventable account for over 50% of the disease burden.[2] In a hospital based study in ayub teaching hospital, abbotabad, six maternal deaths were recorded during study period. The major causative factors were hemorrhage, eclampsia, sepsis, anesthetic complications and hepatic encephalopathy. Maternal mortality ratio was 12.7/1000 live births (26/2040). The age range was between 18-42 years. Most of them (69%) were grand multiparas (Parity > 5). Education, antenatal booking and socio-economic status were poor.[3] The MMRs reported from hospitals vary between 17 in a private tertiary hospital to 2,736 in a government tertiary hospital. In the community the range is from 160 in Sindh to 673 in Khuzdar. Data for different periods of time from three tertiary public hospitals, two in the south and one in the north of Pakistan, show no decrease in MMRs [4]. In a study from Aga Khan University, Karachi, The female mortality rate was 151 per 100,000 women aged 10-49 years and the maternal mortality ratio was 281 per 100,000 livebirths. The leading causes of deaths among women were complications of pregnancy (28%), infectious diseases (25%), cardiovascular diseases (21%), neoplasia (11%) and trauma (11%).[5]

Present epidemiological survey was therefore conducted in rural areas of Peshawar to determine the maternal mortality rate (MMR) and to appreciate the factors contributing to maternal mortality.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A descriptive observational survey was conducted in Palusai village near Peshawar University, Peshawar, from December 2004 to December 2005.

Two hundreds houses were included in the study. Of those houses 400 women in their reproductive ages were selected.

Inclusion criteria were all married women in their reproductive ages. Relatives were interview in case of those ladies who had died during pregnancy or cause related to pregnancy. Unmarried women in their reproductive ages were excluded.

 

 

 

A detailed history of the respondents was taken with the help of a pre-designed questionnaire, prepared in accordance with the objectives of this study. Questionnaire contained preliminary information regarding age, address and education of the respondents. It also contained information's about the risk factors that can lead to maternal death including socioeconomic factors, marital factors and obstetric factors.

Finally statistical analysis of the data was performed and association of risk factors with maternal mortality was studied.

RESULTS

This epidemiological; survey cover a total of 200 houses and 400 women in their reproductive ages. The average number of married women per house was two. A total of five maternal deaths were recorded during the survey, from December 2004 to November 2005. The total births according to the local BHU in the same period were 1056.Maternal mortality rate is the number of maternal deaths related to childbearing divided by the number of live births (or by the number of live births + fetal deaths) in that year. And is expressed as mother dying per 1000 live births. In our study the MMR will be,

MMR: 5(1000) /1056= 4.73/1000

Percentage Mortality: 5(100)/400 =1.25%

Socioeconomic factors: In Socioeconomic factors related to maternal mortality, 43% of the women living in kaccha (mud made) houses. Sixty one percent had drinking water supply from tube wells. Most of the women (49%)were living in houses with monthly income less than 5000/month. (Table No- I)

Marital factors: Sixty percent of the deliveries took place at home. Of total 57.5% women had no education. The age at marriage was less than 15 years for 17.25% of women and between 16-20 years in 47% of the clients. Thirty percent were vaccinated for TT only and 16% for both TT and MMR during pregnancy. 72% had not utilized any iron supplements during pregnancy. (Table No-II)

Obstetric factors: The interval between two childbirths was less than two years for 59% cases. Sixty two percent of the ladies missed to visit signally even to antenatal care center through out their pregnancy. In 60% of women the deliveries recorded in home environment. (Table No-III)

DISCUSSION

In order to achieve the millennium development goals (MDGs), Pakistan would require a fundamental shift in its policy and strategic directions. Along with allocation of significant additional resources for health, it needs to review and reprioritize the use of existing resources, focusing more on primary health care. Pakistan must also adopt a holistic integrated approach that views health, education, and other social sector development as intrinsically interrelated and interwoven [6]. In present study five maternal deaths were recorded as a whole. Maternal mortality ratio was 4.73/1000 live births (5/1056), and percentage mortality was 1.25%. Our finding correlates with the findings of Begum S et al [3].

In Socioeconomic factors related to maternal mortality, 43% of the women living in kaccha (mud made) houses. Sixty one percent had drinking water supply from tube wells. Most of the women (49%)were living in houses with monthly income less than 5000/month. In another study by Kazmi S, [7] from Karachi the participants were largely poor, illiterate, and of reproductive age. In the rural context of only minimal access to quality institutional care services, most rural women delivered at home with the aid of traditional birth attendants (TBA). The decision to deliver at home was reached by a combination of women's high degree of trust in the services of TBAs and their concern about costs and convenience.

The age at marriage was less than 15 years for 17.25% of women and between 16-20 years in 47% of the clients. In Germany there is a rapid decrease in infant and maternal mortality. Since the 80s of the twentieth century the average age at marriage of until then unmarried persons as well as the number of single mothers show a permanent increase. Generally, the average age of mothers increased (for live and legitimate births) [8]. Thirty percent were vaccinated for TT only and 16% for both tetanus toxoid (TT) and measles, mump and rubella (MMR) during pregnancy. 72% had not utilized any iron supplements during pregnancy. MMR is inversely related to contraceptive prevalence rates, presence of trained attendants during delivery, and adult female literacy rates.

Ninety percent of the South Asian region had coverage with BCG immunization, followed by DPT, OPV, and measles immunization. Maternal tetanus toxoid was 69%.[9] In our study sixty two percent of the ladies missed to visit signally even to antenatal care center through out their pregnancy. In a UN study from Punjab and north west frontier provinces of Pakistan, out of 170 facilities only 22 were providing basic and 37 comprehensive emergency obstetric care (EmOC) services in the areas studied. Only 5.7% of births occurred in EmOC health facilities. Met need was 9% and 0.5% of women gave birth by cesarean section. The case fatality rate was a low 0.7%, probably due to poor record keeping. Access and several indicators were better in NWFP than in Punjab. [10]

In our findings the interval between two childbirths was less than two years for 59% cases. The odds of dying in the neonatal and post-neonatal period is 2.27 and 2.12 times higher respectively for children born after preceding birth intervals of one year or less compared to children born after longer intervals. Children born within two years of a subsequent birth are at 4.09 times higher risk of dying in the second year of life than children whose mother gave birth more than 2 years after the index birth.[11]

CONCLUSION

Socioeconomic factors mainly contributing top maternal mortality in the area followed by marital and obstetric factors. There is need for more actions to decrease maternal morality by increasing awareness, improving life style of the women, and providing better health facilities at doorstep. Most maternal deaths are preventable. The provision of skilled care and timely management of complications can lower maternal mortality in our setup.


Table 1. . Socioeconomic variables of women. Total number of women=400

Socioeconomic variables of women Number of women Percentage of total (%)
1. Housing condition    
Kaccha (mud made) house 172 43%
Pakka bricks made) house 92 23%
Mixed house 136 34%
2. Source of drinking water    
Tube wells 246 61.5%
Hand pumps 92 23%
Miscellaneous sources 62 15.5%
3. Monthly income in home    
Less than 5000/month 195 48.75%
5000-20,000/month 146 36.5%
More than 20,000/month 59 14.75%

Table 2. . Marital factors that can lead to maternal mortality. Total number of women=400

Variables Recorded Number of women Percentage of total (%)
1. Education level of women    
Illiterate 230 57.5%
Primary education 85 47%
Matriculate 63 28.5%
Secondary education 22 7.25%
2. Age of marriage    
Less than 15 years 69 17.25%
15 to 20 years 188 47%
21-25 years 114 28.5%
More than 25 years 29 7.25%
3. Nutrition supplements during pregnancy    
Yes 291 72.75%
No 109 27.25%
4. Vaccination during pregnancy    
Not at all 216 54%
TT done only 120 30%
TT plus MMR done 64 16%

Table 3. Obstetrics factors that can lead to maternal mortality. Total number of the respondents: 400

Variables Recorded Number of women Percentage of total (%)
1. Antenatal visits    
No visit to antenatal clinic 248 62%
One or more visits 152 38%
2. Interval between child births    
One years 57 19.25%
1- 2 years 180 45%
3 years 136 34%
> Three years 27 6.75%
3. Number roof children born to deceased (total number= 5)    
1-3 children 1 20%
4-6children 3 60%
> 6 children 1 20%
4. Place of delivery    
Home 240 60%
Government Hospital 118 29.5%
Private clinics 42 10.5%

 


REFERENCES
1. Mahaini R, Mahmoud H. Maternal health in the eastern Mediterranean region of the World Health Organization. East Mediterr Health J, 2005 Jul;11(4):532-8.
2. Siddiqi S, Haq IU, Ghaffar A, Akhtar T, Mahaini R. Pakistan's maternal and child health policy: analysis, lessons and the way forward. Health Policy, 2004 Jul;69(1):117-30.
3. Begum S, Aziz-Un-Nisa, Begum I. Analysis of maternal mortality in a tertiary care hospital to determine causes and preventable factors. J Ayub Med Coll Abbotabad, 2003 Apr-Jun; 15(2): 49-52.
4. Jafarey SN. Maternal mortality in Pakistan--compilation of available data. J Pak Med Assoc, 2002; 52(12): 49-52.
5. Fikree FF, Karim MS, Midhet F, Berendes HW. Causes of reproductive age mortality in low socioeconomic settlements of Karachi. J Pak Med Assoc, 1993 Oct; 43(10): 208-12.
6. Islam A. Health-related millennium development goals: policy challenges for Pakistan. J Pak Med Assoc, 2004 Apr; 54(4): 175-81.
 
7. Kazmi S. Pakistan: consumer satisfaction and dissatisfaction with maternal and child health services. World Health Stat Q, 1995; 48(1): 55-9.
8. Jaeger U, Finke L, Zellner K. Secular trends of demographic parameters, [Article in German]. Anthropol Anz, 2004 Sep; 62(3): 347-62.
9. Ramji S. MCH indicators in south Asia. Indian Pediatr, 1997 May; 34(5): 420-3.
10 Ali M, Hotta M, Kuroiwa C, Ushijima H. Emergency obstetric care in Pakistan: potential for reduced maternal mortality through improved basic EmOC facilities, services, and access. Int J Gynaecol Obstet, 2005 Oct; 91(1): 105-12.
11. Ronsmans C. Birth spacing and child survival in rural Senegal Int J Epidemiol, 1996 Oct; 25(5): 989-97.