Mamun-Al-Mahtab,
K. M. Mamun Murshed, Uttam Kumar Barua,
Nuzhat Choudhury, K. M. Shahnoor Hossain,
Md. Mahbubur Rahman, Rooh-e-Zakaria,
Swati Munshi, Rima Afroza Alia,
Bangladesh
Primary Care Research Network (BPCRN),
Dhaka, Bangladesh
Correspondence to
Dr. Mamun-Al-Mahtab
MSc, MD
Chairman, Bangladesh Primary Care
Research Network (BPCRN)
Email: shwapnil@agni.com
|
Bangladesh
is a small country in South Asia with an
area of 1,44,000 sq. km. and a population
of over 140 million. It is the 8th most
populous country of the world, but in terms
of land area Bangladesh ranks 93rd [1].
The population density is 1060 per sq. km
[2].
Right to healthcare was recognized
as one of the fundamental rights for every
Bangladeshi citizen in the very first constitution
of the newly liberated People's Republic
of Bangladesh in 1972 [3]. Directorate General
of Health Services and later Directorate
of Family Planning was established by the
Government as independent Departments under
the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare,
to provide backbone for delivering primary
health care in Bangladesh.
The Directorate of Family
Planning is concerned with birth control,
maternal and child health while the Directorate
General of Health Services is responsible
for overall health care of the country.
Under these two Departments 341 health complexes
and 2329 health centres have been established
in the country at the sub-district and union
levels respectively, which are the two smallest
administrative units in Bangladesh [4].
The Union Health centres are staffed by
1-2 graduate physicians and a number of
paramedics and traditional birth attendants
(TBA), while 9 graduate physicians and several
nurses, paramedics, TBAs, laboratory technicians
and other support staff are posted in the
sub-district health complexes. However in
most cases, the more remote and peripheral
sub-district health complexes and union
health centres are under-staffed.
The physician: patient ratio
in Bangladesh is 1:4775 [2]. Most physicians
are based in urban areas meaning that the
scenario is even poorer in the rural communities,
where primary health care is provided by
quacks, rural medical practitioners, traditional
medicine practitioners and paramedics. Only
30% of the population of Bangladesh has
access to primary health care [2].
In the urban areas, in big
cities, district towns and municipalities,
people mainly depend on medical graduates,
fresh or experienced, and specialists for
their every day health needs. Specialists
play an important role in providing primary
health care in Bangladesh. No referral is
needed to consult a specialist physician
here. Patients usually consult the respective
specialists based on their initial idea
about their disease. So whereas a patient
with complaints of headache resulting from
a brain tumor may correctly go to a Neurosurgeon
directly at the very beginning, more commonly
they end up in the wrong consultation chambers.
For example patients with irritable bowel
syndrome often consult Hepatologists for
fear of cirrhosis of liver.
Bangladeshi patients can access
primary health care through different gateways,
which adds a huge problem. Not only the
patients suffer because of the huge difference
in the quality and standard of health care
they receive, they are also vulnerable to
mal-treatment in the hands of non-qualified
practitioners (e.g. quacks, rural medical
practitioners, traditional medical practitioners
etc.) Besides, over the years, the situation
has become so difficult and complex that
it will take years to put primary health
care on the right track in Bangladesh. We
are trailing far behind what the Brazilians
have achieved by establishing 'health teams'
comprising GP, nurse, nurse assistants and
community agents with the support of World
Bank [5], [6].
Primary health care in Bangladesh
is financed by both the public and the private
sectors. But the majority of the 140 million
Bangladeshis use the public system. In 2005,
Bangladesh utilized a significant portion
of her gross national product in health
care and a bulk of this money went to primary
health care.
ROLE
OF FAMILY PHYSICIANS IN DELIVERY OF
PRIMARY CARE IN BANGLADESH |
The College of General Practitioners
of Bangladesh has been conducting a Fellowship
programme for general practitioners for
several years with limited success. As the
specialty and the Fellowship offered by
this college were not recognized by the
Bangladesh Medical and Dental Council and
the Bangladesh Government, it attracted
little enthusiasm among medical graduates.
Family medicine has been recognized as an
independent specialty in Bangladesh for
less than a year, although neither the only
medical university in Bangladesh, nor the
medical faculties of the different public
and private universities are offering any
course in Family Medicine as yet. The Bangladesh
College of Physicians and Surgeons has recognized
this specialty and devised the training
programme for residents specializing in
this branch. The development though very
late, received momentum as the Royal College
of General Practitioners of UK selected
Dhaka, the capital city of Bangladesh, as
the Regional Centre for holding clinical
MRCGP examination. With all the international,
regional and local attention it is therefore
expected that the subject will flourish
in Bangladesh in it's own right far sooner
that expected.
|
|
The crude reality however
is that the country will probably have to
wait for a few more years to have her first
set of qualified Family Physicians who can
then contribute in a more useful way to
the advancement of this specialty for the
better interest of not only the subject,
but also the people and the country as a
whole.
The recently introduced training
programme for Family Medicine residents
in Bangladesh is somewhat similar to the
GP training programme in the UK. However,
as of now, the fact remains that the relationship
between primary care physicians and the
specialists is precarious without any type
of coordination by the health system.
CHALLENGES
FOR FAMILY MEDICINE IN BANGLADESH |
Family Medicine in Bangladesh
is faces a number of challenges, namely:
- Lack of health professionals
with clinical competence to act in primary
health care.
- Homogenization of the general
practice in entire Bangladesh with different
realities co-existing.
- Ignorance by specialists
who are, in general, rather dismissive
towards Family Medicine.
- Lack of interest on part
of specialists not wanting to lose their
'specialist family practice'.
- Lack of interest among
fresh medical graduates in Family Medicine.
HOW
FAMILY MEDICINE CAN FLOURISH IN BANGLADESH |
Although a lot depends on
the support of the policy makers and the
Government, specialists involved in 'specialist
general practice' and graduate physicians
engaged in general practice can contribute
effectively in this regard by means of quality
practice and research to prove the effectiveness
of Family Medicine and primary health care.
The integration of teaching and practice
in Family Medicine is important [7]. There
is lack of interest as well as qualified
researchers interested to work in this field
in Bangladesh. It is also important to ensure
delivery of quality primary health care
and to break the vicious cycle of bad clinical
practice by untrained and ill-trained health
professionals. Ensuring adequate employment
and income for the qualified Family Physicians
in the public and private sectors will also
help ensure quality of clinical practice
at primary health care. The initiatives,
however in this regard in Bangladesh, are
so far sparse.
BANGLADESH
PRIMARY CARE RESEARCH NETWORK |
The Bangladesh Primary Care
Research Network (BPCRN) has been established,
with active cooperation from the International
Federation of Primary Care Research Networks
(IFPCRN) and the Pakistan Primary Care Research
Network (PPCRN), where Family Medicine is
most developed in South Asia. The unique
characteristic of BPCRN is that this newly
established organization is headed by and
comprises mostly of specialists with a passionate
approach to Family Medicine while it also
includes graduate general practitioners.
BPCRN looks forward to collaboration with
other regional and international primary
care research networks and primary health
care societies. It is expected that such
collaboration will prove beneficial for
the cause of Family Medicine and ultimately
primary health care not only in Bangladesh,
but in the entire South Asian region, the
home of a bulk of the world's population,
where structured Family Medicine is unfortunately
virtually non-existent.
GOALS
OF BANGLADESH PRIMARY CARE RESEARCH
NETWORK |
- Vision Statement: To promote
skills in research methodology among Family
Physicians.
- To promote and support
primary health care research in Bangladesh.
- To identify issues in
Family Medicine and to address them through
research based on sound scientific principles.
- To conduct affairs of the
network through the following office bearers
to be elected for a period of three years
by the members of the group:
Chairman (1 no.), Vice-Chairman (1-3 nos.),
Honorary Secretary (1 no.), Treasurer
(1 no.), Scientific Secretary (1 no.),
Member (1-5 nos.)
- The network will have an
Advisory Committee comprising of eminent
local, regional and international Family
Medicine Specialists and physicians.
- To ensure regular interaction
between network members through meetings
and e-mails.
- To conduct research to
influence Government policy in favor of
Family Medicine and primary health care.
- To support and promote
collaboration between academic physicians
interested in Family Medicine working
at institutions and universities with
those working in the community.
- To help improve quality
of care provided to patients in the community
by general practitioners through research.
- To present works of the
network at national and international
forums and journals.
- To establish collaboration
with regional and international Family
Medicine Associations and Primary Care
Research Networks.
The aim of establishing structured
primary health care in Bangladesh with Family
Medicine as an independent specialty can
be achieved with priority government support
and sincere cooperation from the medical
fraternity. BPCRN aims to contribute in
achieving this goal in whatever way possible.
|