Fatma Yücel Beyaztas [1]
Halis Dokgöz [2]
Esra Saka [3]
Isil Çitici [3],
Celal Bütün [1]
- Department of Forensic Medicine,
Cumhuriyet University Faculty of
Medicine, Sivas, Turkey
- Department of Forensic Medicine,
Mersin University Faculty of Medicine,
Mersin, Turkey,
- The Council of Forensic Medicine,
Istanbul, Turkey
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Fatma Yücel
Beyaztas
Department of Forensic Medicine, Cumhuriyet
University
Faculty of Medicine 58140 Sivas/Turkey
e-mail: fyucel@cumhuriyet.edu.tr
|
SUMMARY
The aim of
this study is to determine the features
of and changes in the medico-legal
childhood deaths that occurred in
Istanbul, Turkey; and to contribute
to the establishment of a database
on childhood deaths. In this study,
the childhood deaths were evaluated
with respect to age, sex, causes of
deaths and the origins. The records
of the autopsies performed in the
Council of Forensic Medicine in Turkey
between the years 1997-2001 were reviewed.
1,568 of 14,467 deaths were found
to be in the childhood age range of
0-18. 1047 (66.8%) of those children
were male of gender and 521 (33.2%)
were female. The commonly encountered
origins of childhood deaths were sudden-unexpected
causes in early childhood, accidents
in the playing age, homicide and suicide
in the adolescents. Among all the
deaths, 571 cases (36.4%) were seen
in the age group of 0-6 years. Accidents
account for 619 cases (39.3%), blunt
traumas (156 cases) present the most
common cause of deaths. In order to
prevent childhood deaths, preventive
and curative health services should
be strengthened, providing training
programs for parents, and should be
a concern of the government bodies
and civil society. Meanwhile, starting
with the efforts of support and training;
all measures must be taken in order
to activate the United Nations Child
Rights Contract.
|
Key
Words: Childhood, autopsy, origin of
death, medico-legal death, preventable death.
The arrangement of studies
on the causes of childhood deaths and recording
the findings are very important. Establishing
a system that serves to explore all childhood
deaths will provide the means of observing
these cases. In addition, due to religious
beliefs and social reasons cases of suicide
are not recorded. With the experiences of
countries, that have developed systemic
mechanisms have shown that death could be
possible in the majority of cases of violence
and negligence (1-3).
The Declaration of Children's
Rights focuses not only on the basic right
to life but also on the contribution of
health and training efforts, concerned with
the development of the child. At this point
establishment of specific mechanisms that
will let us explore, record and report all
childhood deaths is a requirement. The causes
of these deaths are extremely important
(4).
The most important characteristic
of child injury deaths is the fact that
many, if not most, can be prevented (5,6).
Saunders et al. (7) have found that 2.7%
of natural deaths and 96% of injury deaths
are preventable.
The aim of this study is to evaluate the
various features of the medico-legal childhood
deaths in Istanbul, Turkey; and to contribute
to the establishment of a database on childhood
deaths.
The records of medico-legal
autopsies of the 0-18 age group performed
in the Council of Forensic Medicine, Ministry
of Justice, Istanbul for the years 1997-2001,
were separated into four age groups (0-6,
7-11, 12-15, 16-18). The separation was
carried out according to existing age groups
specified in child development and legal
practice. Our study field, Istanbul, is
the largest city of Turkey with a population
of 10,018,735.
The cases are grouped
as homicides, suicides, accidents, sudden-unexpected
deaths (natural deaths and undetermined
deaths). Age, sex and causes of deaths of
each group were studied.
In this study, childhood
deaths according to the causes and origins
were evaluated. The records of the autopsies
performed in the Council of Forensic Medicine
in Istanbul, Turkey between the years 1997-2001
were reviewed. 14,467 medico-legal deaths
were investigated in Istanbulover a period
of five years. 1,568 (10.8%) of all deaths
comprised by our study population were children
(0-18 age).
1,047 (66.8%) of those
children were male and 521 (33.2%) were
female (Figure 1).
The distribution of the years is presented.
In a period of five years, 1,568 autopsies
were performed on children (Figure
2).
|
|
Evaluation of all childhood
deaths (n=1,568) revealed that 116 cases
(7.4%) were caused by suicides (Figures
3, 4), 609 cases (38.8%) were accidents
(Figure 5), 204 cases
(13%) were homicides (Figure 6), 188 cases
(12%) were natural deaths and 451 cases
(28.8%) were unidentified deaths (Table
1).
Of 116 suicides, 78 cases
(73.6%) were due to hanging, and 13 cases
(12.3%) firearms, 11 cases (10.4%) fall,
3 cases (2.8%) intoxication, and 1 case
(0.9%) CO poisoning (Figure
4).
Blunt traumas account
for 25% (156 cases) of the 619 cases that
were determined as accidents. 22% (137 cases)
of accidents were drowning cases (Figure
5).
Of 204 homicides in childhood
deaths, 80 cases (39.2%) were associated
with stabbing, 76 cases (37.3%) with firearms
and 31 cases (15.2%) with strangulation
(Figure 6).
Respiratory - cardiovascular
diseases (n=119; 63.3 %) are the leading
cause of deaths in natural deaths. Infectious
diseases with 22.9% (n=43) are the second
most common cause of natural deaths (Figure
7).
The term "child"
is accepted as the period of 0-18 years
of age according to the Declaration of Children
Rights. Childhood deaths present various
features with respect to age, sex, developmental
stage, social and cultural context, geographical
location and life styles of the family (1,8).
Investigation of childhood autopsies according
to the groups is important especially for
determining the causes and prevention of
childhood injuries and deaths. Accidents
and natural deaths are the common causes
of the deaths in children like in adults
(8,9).
In this study, childhood
deaths according to the causes and the origins
of deaths were evaluated. The records of
the autopsies performed in the National
Institute of Forensic Medicine in Turkey
between the years 1997-2001 were reviewed
and 1,568 of 14,467 deaths were found to
be in the childhood age range of 0-18. These
cases of 0-18 age group, 1,047 (66.8%) were
male and 521 (33.2%) were female.
Deaths caused by accidents,
as those in the literature, are the most
widespread death origin. The basic cause
of this condition is that the persons or
institutions taking full responsibility
for the 0-6 age group, particularly, don't
show enough interest (10). In our study,
the ratio of deaths caused by accidents
is 70%.
Blunt injuries are the
leading causes of deaths in children under
18 years of age (11). In this study; 156
(25%) blunt traumas and 154 (25%) CO poisoning
cases were mostly seen due to accident.
Drowning (n=137, 22%) was accidentally the
second cause of death. Drowning cases usually
occurred at sea.
Although suicides are
rarely seen in the younger age group and
early adolescence, they present a growing
risk in older age groups. Preventing suicides
in adolescence has become the main concern
(12). The autopsy records of the Bonn Institute
of Forensic Medicine and the database of
the Bonn police authorities from 1989 to
1998 were retrospectively analyzed for this
phenomenon. This search revealed 37 respective
suicides involving 23 male (62%) and 14
female (38%) victims. The ages ranged from
10 to 21 years with the prevalence sharply
increasing in adolescents and young adults
(1). For suicides, methods like hanging,
intoxication and firearms are mostly used
(11). In our study, 71 cases of our 106
suicide cases were in the 16-18 age groups.
Hanging (73.6%) was the most common method
of suicide among all the deaths. In suicide
cases, firearms (12.3%) were the second
biggest cause and fall (10.4%) the third
cause of deaths.
Homicides were inflicted
with stabbing and firearms like other cities
of the world (3). Infantile and adolescent
patterns of homicides are recognized: Child
abuse by parents characterizes the former;
gunshots and other assaults by peers characterize
the latter (13). During 201 homicides over
the five-year period of a study, most of
these deaths occurred in adolescents, but
there were 36 deaths in children under 13
years old. In young children, the assailant
was usually a parent or other family member,
including eight children who were murdered
by their father and six by their mother.
Only three children were murdered by a stranger.
Prevention strategies include decreasing
children's access to guns and improving
parental supervision (14). In our study,
of 204 homicides in childhood, 80 (39.2%)
cases were associated with stabbing, 76
(37.3%) firearms, 31 (15.2%) strangulation,
15 (7.4%) blunt traumas, and 2 (1%) burns.
117 (57.3%) of 204 homicide cases were in
the 16-18 age group.
The commonly encountered origins of childhood
deaths were natural causes in early childhood,
accidents in the playing age, and homicide
and suicide in the adolescents (3). Infections
are the most common cause of natural deaths
in children in Cyprus. It is common especially
in infants and this can be explained with
the developing immune system in this period.
This emphasizes the importance of preventive
medicine (8). Deaths due to infectious diseases
took the first place and undetermined deaths
came among the whole death causes in the
0-6 age group (11). In our study, respiratory
- cardiovascular diseases (n=119; 63.3%)
and infections (n=43; 22.9%) are the common
causes of natural deaths in children.
Investigation of childhood
autopsies according to the origins, is important
especially for determining the causes and
prevention of childhood injuries and deaths.
Accidents are the most common origin of
the deaths in children.
Childhood deaths, especially
intentional-preventable injury cases, enhance
the liability of those who are responsible
for the care and supervision of children.
So, training programs should be provided
for parents, to prevent childhood injuries
In order to prevent childhood deaths, preventive
and curative health services should be strengthened,
and education within the individual and
social level should be a concern of the
government bodies and civil society. Meanwhile,
starting with the efforts of support and
education; all measures must be taken in
order to activate the United Nations Child
Rights Contract in Turkey.
. |